Connected lighting supportAustin, Texas, USA · Global projects
Lighting Notes

We Saved $1,410 on High Bay Lights. The Hidden Costs Came to $2,200.

2026-11-03 by Henrik Sorensen

I was sitting on a fold-out chair in the unfinished lobby of a 60-room boutique hotel in Portland, Oregon, when I realized I’d made a $2,200 mistake.

It was August 2023. The ceiling above me was bare concrete. The blueprints were covered in sticky notes. And the high bay lighting quote I’d approved six months earlier was already causing problems I hadn’t planned for.

I’m a procurement manager at a 120-person commercial construction firm. I’ve managed our lighting and electrical budget — about $4.2 million a year — for six years. I’ve negotiated with over 40 vendors, and every order goes into our cost tracking system. I’m not new at this.

But high bay lights? That was a lesson I hadn’t learned yet.

The Setup

This was our first boutique hotel project. Four floors, a rooftop restaurant, an outdoor patio, a small spa, and a back-of-house area the size of a small warehouse.

The decorative lighting was the easy part. We’d specified Visual Comfort pieces throughout the public spaces — a Talia chandelier in the lobby, a pair of Maurice chandeliers down the corridor, candle chandeliers in the restaurant, and Visual Comfort outdoor light fixtures for the entrance and patio. Nobody blinked at the price on those. Those were the pieces guests would photograph.

The high bay lights were a different story. For the loading dock, the back-of-house corridors, and the employee break area, we needed industrial fixtures. The electrical engineer’s spec called for a specific foot-candle level. I called it in.

The Quote

I got two quotes.

The first came from a regional distributor we’d worked with before. Their fixture was $95 per unit. The second came from an online supplier I’d found through a procurement marketplace. Their fixture was $48 per unit. Both claimed similar lumens. Both had a 5-year warranty on paper.

I went back and forth between them for three days. The regional distributor had a local rep, a 48-hour replacement warranty, and fixtures I’d seen on two other projects. The online supplier had the lower price tag and a spec sheet that looked identical.

The numbers said go with the cheaper option. But something felt off. I couldn’t find a single local project using their fixtures. I told myself it didn’t matter.

It mattered. I ordered 30 units at $48 each — $1,440 versus $2,850. That was a $1,410 savings. I noted it in my monthly report and moved on.

The Problems Start

About four months after installation, the issues showed up.

First, the fixtures weren’t all the same color temperature. The spec said 4000K. Some were warm white. Some were almost daylight. In the locker room, one fixture looked like a dentist’s office and the one next to it looked like a sauna. We had to swap out the LED boards on eight units — $446 including labor.

Then two fixtures started flickering. Then four. Then six. By month five, six of the 30 had failed entirely — dead drivers. I called the supplier. Their “5-year warranty” required me to ship each failed unit to their facility at our cost for “evaluation” before they’d ship a replacement. That would take 6-8 weeks.

We couldn’t wait. I bought replacements locally — $48 each plus $45 labor per unit. That’s $558.

The kicker came during the electrical inspection. The inspector walked through with a light meter. The high bay fixtures were underperforming. The cheap supplier claimed 11,000 lumens. Actual output was closer to 9,200. The foot-candle readings didn’t meet the engineer’s spec. We had to add four more fixtures to the loading dock and rewire part of the circuit. Another $372.

And because the inspection was delayed, we pushed the decorative lighting install to the following weekend. Two electricians, eight hours, overtime rates. $880.

The Real Bill

By the time we finished resolving the high bay issues, we’d spent:

  • $558 on replacements and labor
  • $446 on LED board swaps
  • $372 on extra fixtures and rewiring
  • $880 on a Saturday shift to finish the installation before the rescheduled inspection

Total: $2,256. The “savings” were $1,410. We were $846 in the hole. And I’d spent three weeks of early mornings on the phone with the supplier, the electrician, and the hotel owner — who kept asking why the lights in the locker room looked like a broken tanning bed.

To be fair, the Visual Comfort order went fine. No drama. It arrived on time and looked like the spec sheet. The difference, I later realized, wasn’t about the brand. It was about the process. We went through an authorized dealer with a local rep who answered the phone. For the high bay order, we went with the cheapest quote from a website with no local presence and no one to call when things went wrong.

I don’t have hard data on how often this happens across the industry, but based on my own records, it’s about half the time. The low quote wins on the spreadsheet, but loses in real life.

What I Took Away

Here’s what changed after that project:

1. The cheapest quote is a starting point, not a finish line. The $48 fixture wasn’t $48 when you factored in the labor, the replacements, and the inspection delays. The $95 fixture would’ve cost $2,850 upfront but zero after that. That’s not a 50% savings — it’s a 14% premium that would’ve saved me $846 and three weeks of stress.

2. Warranty terms matter more than warranty length. Both suppliers offered a 5-year warranty. But the cheap supplier’s warranty required shipping units back first. The regional distributor’s warranty included a local replacement within 48 hours. That’s a huge difference — one you don’t think about until you’re in the middle of it.

3. Ask what “lumens” actually means. Per FTC advertising guidelines, performance claims — including light output — must be “truthful, not misleading, and substantiated with evidence.” But that doesn’t mean every supplier gets it right. Ask for an independent test report, or at least a spec sheet from a lab. If they can’t provide it, that’s a signal.

4. Budget for the redo. I now add a 15% contingency line to every lighting budget — not for materials, but for the “we might need to swap these out” problem. Our procurement policy now requires three quotes minimum and a call with a past customer for any vendor we haven’t used before.

I wish I had tracked our high bay failure rates more carefully over the years. What I can tell you anecdotally is that the 20% failure rate we saw on this project was an outlier — usually it’s closer to 8-10%. But even 8% is enough to blow up a budget when you’re buying 30 fixtures.

The Next Project

The hotel opened six days late. The owner was understanding — he’s a contractor himself. But I’ll be honest: the Visual Comfort chandelier in the lobby was the first thing guests saw, and the high bay fixtures in the back were the last thing I wanted to think about.

About a year later, we did another hotel project. Same approach on the decorative lighting — Visual Comfort throughout, specified by name, ordered through the dealer. But for the high bay lights, I called the regional distributor first. I paid $95 per unit. No drama. No replacements. No Saturday shifts.

If you’re asking yourself “how many high bay lights do I need?” the math is the easy part. The harder question is: what’s the real cost of the light you’re buying?

Because from my experience, the answer is almost never the number on the quote.

Discuss a lighting project

Share the application, fixture family, control intent, and timing if this article connects to an active specification question.